Choosing an SEO company small business owners can verify

Agencies with a verified published price

How to hire an SEO company as a small business

1. Write down the outcome before you take a call. Not rankings. The outcome: more booked jobs, more quote requests, more calls before ten in the morning. Write the current number down too, however rough. A provider who cannot connect their plan to that number is selling activity, and you will not be able to judge month six without a starting point recorded now.
2. Filter by published price and minimum first. The single fastest filter is the smallest engagement a provider will accept. It removes most of a shortlist in one email and costs you nothing. Where a starting retainer is published, treat it as a floor rather than the likely bill, and ask what scope that floor actually covers.
3. Use Google's own hiring questions on the first call. Google publishes guidance for buyers hiring a search vendor: ask for examples of past work and success stories you can look up, ask what results are expected and when, and be wary of anyone claiming a special relationship with Google or guaranteeing a number one ranking.
4. Own the accounts, then grant access. Create the Search Console property, the analytics property and the business profile in your own name, then invite the agency. Agencies that create these for you can walk away with your history. This one decision determines whether leaving a provider is a handover or a restart.
5. Fix the reporting definitions in the contract. Agree what counts as a lead, how a call is attributed, which queries are tracked and how often you get the report. Disputes at month nine are almost always definition disputes, and definitions are free to settle in month zero.

What actually moves a small business quote

Three inputs move the number more than anything else. Competitive density comes first: a plumber in a town of forty thousand and a plumber in a metro area are quoted for the same words and are not doing the same job, because the second is competing against firms with years of accumulated content and links. Second is the state of what you already have. A site that is slow, unreadable on a phone or built on a platform nobody can edit turns month one into remediation, and honest providers price that separately rather than burying it in the retainer. Third is content volume, since the pages that answer buyer questions are the largest recurring cost in any legitimate programme.

What should not move the price much is the size of your company, and yet it often does, because a small buyer is assumed to be less able to compare. That is precisely why published pricing is worth weighting in a shortlist. It is not that a published number is a better number, it is that a provider who competes on a visible price has less room to quote you by how the room feels. Take the published figures for your scope, establish a reference range, then use it as the anchor when you take the calls that produce no number at all.

The claims that should end a conversation

Google states plainly that no one can guarantee a top ranking, so a guaranteed number one in a proposal is a claim contradicted by the search engine it concerns. The same goes for an unsolicited email promising to fix errors it has not been shown, a special relationship with Google, or a refusal to explain methods in plain language on the grounds of proprietary technique. Google's spam policies describe the tactics that carry real risk, including link schemes and thin, scaled content produced to game rankings, and those risks land on your domain rather than on the agency's.

Advertising claims sit with you as well. The FTC's guidance for small business advertisers is that claims have to be truthful and substantiated before they run, and testimonials on your site are covered too. If a provider writes your copy, someone on your side still has to be able to back up what it says. A supplier who resists that check is telling you where their content comes from.

What our index records, and what it does not

We record what each agency publishes on its own site, with the date we checked: any stated price or starting retainer, any disclosed minimum, whether clients are named, and the services claimed in house. We do not score quality, we do not sell placement and we do not rank on commission. The point of the index is to make the reading half of your evaluation fast, so that your calls are spent on the things reading cannot answer.

The practical use is a reference range. Line up the providers who publish for the scope you actually want, note where the middle of that range sits, and take that number into the meetings. A small business that walks into a sales call with a market reference price rarely gets quoted an enterprise programme for a five page site, and that alone is usually worth more than the hours the comparison takes.

Questions people actually ask

Is a cheap monthly SEO package ever worth buying?

Sometimes, if you know what it is. At the lowest tiers you are usually buying listing maintenance, a monthly report and a small amount of content, which is genuinely useful for a local business with an accurate site and no competition problem. What it is not is a programme that will move a contested commercial query. The failure is a mismatch between the tier bought and the outcome expected.

Should I hire a freelancer or an agency?

A capable freelancer is often better value at a small scope, because you get the practitioner rather than an account manager relaying to a junior. The trade is continuity and breadth: one person takes holidays and does not cover design, development and paid media. Ask either candidate the same question, which is who does the work and what happens when that person is unavailable.

How long before I should expect to see anything?

Technical fixes and listing corrections can show within weeks. Content and authority work is measured in quarters, and Google's own guidance notes some changes take effect in hours while others take months. Judge month three on leading signals such as pages published, impressions and queries appearing, and judge month nine on enquiries.

What should I ask for in the first report?

The work done with links to it, the queries you now appear for that you did not before, impressions and clicks from Search Console rather than a third party rank tracker alone, and the enquiries attributed to search with the method of attribution stated. If a first report contains only rankings for terms you chose, you cannot tell whether anything commercial happened.

Browse agencies by specialty

• SEO agencies with verified facts
• PPC agencies with verified facts
• Social media agencies with verified facts
• Content marketing agencies with verified facts
• Email marketing agencies with verified facts
• Performance marketing agencies with verified facts