Buy personal injury leads

Personal injury is the most expensive category in American consumer legal marketing, and the lead market that has grown around it is correspondingly aggressive. Buying leads can work, and it can also produce a stack of invoices for calls that were sold to three other firms, generated by advertising nobody in your office has seen, in a form your state bar may not permit. The variables that decide which outcome you get are knowable before you sign: where the lead came from, who else received it, how it is priced, and how disputes are handled. We compare vendors on the evidence they publish, and this page explains what to check before any money changes hands.

median disclosed retainer, per month (USD)
$2,000
agencies with a verified published price
21
verified agencies in the index
134

Figures on this page come from the 134-agency verified catalog: each one was fetched from the agency's own published page and matched verbatim, with the source and retrieval date stored beside it.

Agencies with a verified published price

Agency Disclosed starting price Evidenced specialties HQ Source Checked
Prosperity Media 3 verified facts AUD 2,000/mo Content marketingSEO Surry Hills (Sydney), NSW, AU prosperitymedia.com.au August 2026
SimpleTiger 3 verified facts $5,000/mo SEO Sarasota, FL simpletiger.com August 2026
Yoghurt Digital 3 verified facts AUD 2,000/mo PPC & paid searchSEOSocial media marketing Surry Hills (Sydney), NSW, AU yoghurtdigital.com.au August 2026
Boulder SEO Marketing 2 verified facts $2,000/mo SEO Boulder, CO boulderseomarketing.com August 2026
EZMarketing 2 verified facts $1,500/mo PPC & paid searchSEO Lancaster, PA ezmarketing.com August 2026
Firebelly Marketing 2 verified facts $3,000/mo Social media marketing Indianapolis, IN firebellymarketing.com August 2026
Grounds for Promotion 2 verified facts $5,000/mo PPC & paid searchSEO Boulder, CO groundsforpromotion.com August 2026
Hook Agency 2 verified facts $2,800/mo PPC & paid searchSEO Minneapolis, MN hookagency.com August 2026
Kalungi 2 verified facts $50,000/mo Content marketing Kirkland, WA kalungi.com August 2026
The SEO Room 2 verified facts AUD 1,500/mo Content marketingSEO Canning Vale (Perth), WA, AU seoroom.com.au August 2026
Thrive Internet Marketing Agency 2 verified facts $500/mo SEO Arlington, TX thriveagency.com August 2026
Ciphers Digital Marketing 1 verified fact $2,500/mo SEO Gilbert, AZ ciphersdigital.com August 2026

What to establish before you buy

  1. Trace the source of every lead. Ask exactly where leads originate: the vendor's own search advertising, an organic site they own, a network of affiliates, or purchased traffic they resell. Affiliate networks are where the worst practices live, and a vendor that cannot or will not describe its sources is describing them by refusing.
  2. Settle exclusivity and resale in writing. Exclusive leads cost more and are worth more; shared leads mean you are racing two or three firms to the phone. Get the number of buyers per lead in the contract, along with whether unsold or aged leads are later resold, because both change the economics entirely.
  3. Confirm the marketing complies where you practise. Lawyer advertising and client solicitation are regulated by your state bar, and buying leads generated by someone else's advertising does not move that responsibility off you. Review the actual ad creative and intake scripts, and take the compliance question to your own counsel rather than to the vendor.
  4. Define a billable lead and a credit process. Agree what counts: jurisdiction, case type, injury threshold, time since incident, and whether the person actually consented to contact. Then agree how you dispute one and what the credit window is. Vendors differ enormously here and the difference is most of your real cost per case.

How pricing works and what it hides

Leads are sold per lead, per qualified call, per signed case, or on a monthly package with a volume floor. Per lead is the most common and the least aligned, since the vendor is paid whether or not the person had a case. Per call with a duration threshold is better, because it filters the accidental and the abandoned. Per signed case is the most aligned and the least available, and where it exists it is often structured in ways that raise fee-sharing questions your bar rules may treat seriously. Whatever the model, the number that matters is not the price per lead but the cost per signed case, and you cannot know it until you have run enough volume to measure the conversion rate honestly.

Two costs are routinely omitted from vendor arithmetic. Intake capacity is the first: shared leads reward whoever calls back fastest, so if your office cannot respond within minutes, the shared product will underperform its advertised conversion rate no matter who supplies it. Rejection overhead is the second: every out-of-jurisdiction or out-of-scope lead consumes staff time before it is credited, and a vendor with a slow credit process is charging you twice.

The compliance edges that matter most

Three areas deserve your own review rather than a vendor assurance. Consent to contact: leads generated through forms with buried or missing consent language, or through call centres dialling lists, expose the buyer as well as the seller, and telemarketing rules govern how consumers may be contacted and what records of consent must exist. Advertising accuracy: creative that implies a guaranteed outcome or a relationship with a firm that does not exist is a problem for the firm whose name ends up attached. And solicitation: rules on live contact with prospective clients differ meaningfully between states, and a vendor operating nationally will usually price to the most permissive one.

The practical protection is simple and rarely taken: ask to see the actual landing pages, forms and scripts, in the states where you practise, before you sign. A reputable vendor will show you. If the answer is that the creative is proprietary, you are being asked to put your firm's name behind advertising you are not permitted to read.

Questions people actually ask

Are exclusive leads worth the higher price?
Usually, if your intake is anything short of instant. With shared leads the fastest caller wins and you pay full price for the losses. Run both for a defined period, measure cost per signed case rather than cost per lead, and let that number decide instead of the headline price.
What conversion rate should I expect?
It varies so widely by source, case type, exclusivity and intake speed that any vendor quoting a rate up front is quoting a best case. Insist on a paid pilot with enough volume to measure your own rate, and treat the pilot as the price of information rather than as a discount negotiation.
Is buying leads better than building my own marketing?
They answer different questions. Bought leads fill capacity now and stop the moment you stop paying. Owned marketing costs more up front and compounds. Most firms that end up in a good position use purchased volume to smooth gaps while building assets that make the purchase optional.
Who is responsible if the advertising breaks a rule?
In practice your firm carries the reputational and regulatory exposure attached to its own name, whoever wrote the ad. That is why reviewing creative and intake scripts before signing, and having your own counsel confirm the arrangement against your state rules, is not a formality.

Get a shortlist for your project

Free for you; agencies pay us for introductions, which is how this site earns. We may email you about this enquiry and similar services from this site; opt out any time, including from the first message.

Browse agencies by specialty

Cite or embed this figure

The median advertised marketing retainer starting price per month in the US agency market was $2,000 in August 2026, across 21 verified agency facts recorded in FindAgency HQ Pricing Transparency Index.

Cite as: "FindAgency HQ Pricing Transparency Index", updated 2026-08-18, https://findagencyhq.com/buy-personal-injury-leads/.

Embed this figure (plain HTML, no scripts)
median advertised marketing retainer starting price per month · the US agency market · August 2026

$2,000

Middle 50%$500 – $50,000
verified agency facts21

Source: FindAgency HQ Pricing Transparency Index

Get your agency shortlistDescribe your project